Mobile phone icon
View Articles on Mobile
  • RSS Feed
  • Mail

Albert F. Hochwalt, Judging, William F. Brown

Points From The Pros ~ On Judging Field Trials

Reporter, Albert Hochwalt and former editor of the American Field, Bill Brown

Hochwalt felt that a field trial judge was in supreme command at all times and should exercise his prerogatives to keep things under control, to assure equality of competitive conditions, uniformity of opportunity, and elimination of interference. He did not believe there was any need for lengthy rules and regulations. The conditions should be outlined briefly and promulgated regulations permit sufficient latitude for the judges to exercise their discretion in complex situations. Hochwalt always thought that Thomas Johnson of Winnipeg, Manitoba, had the right idea.

In a pamphlet he issued, Mr. Johnson said:

“There is so much bitter dissension about field trial rules and field trial judging that I will give my views. The fact is, rules are not required when you get judges who know their business, but unfortunately you cannot get them to think alike. The main case of this is the different opinions held by different judges of what constitutes field trial ability and a field trial dog. Some judges want dogs to get out of sight and stay out of sight, and place more on ‘leg work’ than “brain work.’ If their kind of dog gets away and stays away, but is eventually found on point, he is glorified as a ‘class’ dog. Then there are judges who want a dog to work out his ground intelligently, to keep busy, and if he keeps on the course and finds birds twice while the crowd is hunting for the class dog, they give him more credit than they would a straight-liner that got lost and was found pointing. The Northwestern Club (Canada) had practically no rules, yet it sounds paradoxical to say that it had, in my opinion, the best ever made, and so concise there could be no mistake in interpreting them; they were as follows: ‘The club has no running rules. It will engage competent judges and instruct them to give the greatest credit to fast, wide-ranging dogs that work to and for the gun, that are game finders and can handle their game in a high-classed finished manner.’ “I don’t expect that even a majority of field trial supporters will agree with my opinion, especially the novice who has just identified himself with the sport. To these I would say, in the words of the minister that I heard debating with members of his flock on a street corner in Grand Junction, Tenn.: ‘Well gentlemen, if yo’ all think that there’s mo’ intelligence in the pew than in the pulpit, den I’se got nothin mo’ to say.’”

William F. Brown
Albert Frederick Hochwalt — A Biography

From the January 23rd, 1988 edition of The American Field



Running Dog


Strideaway is an online publication founded in 2008. We are dedicated to promoting the great sport of American pointing dog field trials, in particular American Field sanctioned trials for pointers and setters. Our objective is to present the voices and ideas of experienced trainers, handlers, breeders and other knowledgeable participants and enthusiasts from the past to the present — amateurs and professionals alike. Whether All-Age or Shooting Dog, Horseback or Walking Trials, we place particular emphasis on wild bird field trials and the dogs that compete in them. We present richly illustrated articles and stories, podcast interviews and other types of media on a regular basis with the hope of providing an ever expanding, searchable archive of information relevant to pointing dog field trials.Read article

This website is dedicated to our ever faithful friend, Bill Allen who passed away peacefully and surrounded by his loving family on January 25, 2022 at the age of 96. We will miss him but he left us the greatest of gifts, his wonderful writings in a book we published for the 3rd time in 2021: The Unforgettables and Other True Fables.

Shop Strideaway!

Books, caps, note cards, decals...and more unique items...many only available in the Strideaway store!Shop Strideaway
Profits help promote field trials!